Learning From Literature

The Anxious Generation by Jonathan Haidt

Purchase Here

The Anxious Generation: How the Great Rewiring of Childhood Is Creating an Epidemic of Mental Illness by Jonathan Haidt is a self-help book published in 2024. 

In recent years, anxiety, depression, and mental health struggles have surged among teens and young adults. But what’s really driving this crisis?

In The Anxious Generation, social psychologist Jonathan Haidt makes a compelling case that the rise of smartphones and social media, particularly around 2010, triggered a massive shift in how young people grow up — and not for the better. Haidt’s book dives into the data, the psychology, and the cultural changes behind the mental health epidemic plaguing Gen Z. 

Enjoy!

Table of Contents

The Great Rewiring of Childhood

The Rise of Adolescent Mental Illness (2010–2015)

  • Between 2010 and 2015, teens shifted their social lives to smartphones and internet-based platforms
  • This digital transformation – termed the Great Rewiring of Childhood – coincides with a dramatic rise in mental health issues
  • Gen Z, the first cohort to go through puberty with smartphones, showed marked increases in:
    • Anxiety
    • Depression
    • Self-harm
    • Suicidal ideation

Gender and Age-Specific Impacts

  • Girls, especially preteen girls, were the hardest hit
  • Boys also saw increases in anxiety and depression, though generally less severe
  • Boys’ mental health struggles and technology use show different patterns, discussed further in later analysis

Global Mental Health Crisis

  • This crisis wasn’t isolated to the U.S.; similar patterns appeared in the U.K., Canada, Australia, Nordic countries
  • Feelings of alienation in school rose globally after 2012
  • Non-Western data is limited, but Western trends are clear and consistent

No Competing Theory Explains the Shift

  • Other factors like the 2008 financial crisis fail to account for the mental health surge across nations and demographics
  • Only the rise of smartphone-centered social life aligns with:
    • Timeline (post-2010)
    • Global scale
    • Age specificity (adolescents)

Childhood as a Critical Period for Cultural Learning

Human Childhood Is Unique

  • Brain reaches 90% of adult size by age 5, but configures over many years
  • Childhood is designed for cultural learning through imitation, exploration, and especially free play

Free Play vs. Phone-Based Childhood

  • Free play is essential for:
    • Social development (e.g., turn-taking, conflict resolution)
    • Physical and emotional resilience
  • Social media and internet use are:
    • Asynchronous and performative
    • Poor substitutes for the attunement and synchrony that real-world play provides

Hijacking of Social Learning Systems

  • Children are wired with:
    • Conformist bias – copy what’s common
    • Prestige bias – follow the popular or admired
  • Social media hijacks these instincts by:
    • Amplifying influencers of questionable value
    • Overriding family and community cultural norms

Sensitive Period of Cultural Imprinting

  • Ages 9 to 15 are a crucial window for cultural identity formation
    • Lessons in these years are more likely to imprint/stick than at other ages
  • Sadly, this is when most kids get their first smartphones, moving their social lives online and reshaping their worldview
Trending
Atomic Habits by James Clear

From Discover Mode to Defend Mode

Two Brain Modes: Discover vs. Defend

  • Young people today are stuck in defend mode:
    • Constant threat monitoring
    • Heightened anxiety
  • Earlier generations were more likely in discover mode:
    • Curious
    • Open to exploration

The Antifragility of Childhood

Safetyism and Fearful Parenting

Rise of Fear-Based Parenting

  • Since the 1980s and ’90s, parenting has grown increasingly fearful due to:
    • Sensationalist media
    • Lower community trust
    • Increased adult supervision
  • Physical oversight has increased, while digital protectionism is almost nonexistent – just when kids need it most

Dangers of Safetyism

  • Safetyism: the belief that safety trumps all other values
  • Consequences:
    • Less risk-taking
    • Weaker coping skills
    • Overreliance on adult intervention

Secure Attachment and Growth

  • Children need to explore from a “secure base”
  • Fearful parenting keeps them stuck at home base, preventing:
    • Independence
    • Confidence
    • Secure emotional development

The Bottom Line

  • Children thrive through real-world, play-based childhoods
  • Phone-based, safety-obsessed childhoods:
    • Limit growth
    • Foster anxiety and fragility
  • If we want stronger, healthier kids:
    • Encourage free play
    • Loosen the grip of smartphones and social media
    • Reclaim the offline world for childhood development

Check out more Self-Help posts!